Review Comment:
The submitted article "Semantic technological framework for integrating software paradigms in organizational solutions" tries to provide an overview of business information systems and their relationship with semantic technologies and software paradigms.
However, it is unclear to me what the actual contribution of this article is:
The authors provide an overview of supposed trends in business information systems. For the most part, this is only of limited interest as this overview mixes too many concepts, and most of them are well-known anyway (like HTML/CSS/PHP, etc.)
This is followed by a long-winded discussion about technological integration, which briefly touches a plethora of vastly different technologies and methodologies. For the greater part of this section, I was unable to follow the author`s line of argument (e.g., while “applications like Hadoop and Mashup” supposedly have “facilitated the rapid structuring of responses”, I fail to see a strong link between Hadoop and Mashup, as they are in my point of view extremely different types of entities. Also, it is unclear how they are achieving this supposed effect.)
The next section then claims to discuss how semantic technologies support software paradigm integration. Despite a lengthy discussion, I still fail to understand how this is supposed to work. The presented software model quite vague, and it is unclear what it achieves, or how effective it is.
As a result, I cannot identify a strong original contribution in this article. Additionally, even as a survey, it falls short as there is no clear line of argument discernable, and the results and conclusions are unclear to me.
Additionally, the article shows several smaller flaws. For example, most diagrams and charts are in a non-English language (Spanish?) and are thus not readable.
In conclusion, I doubt that these shortcomings can be fixed with minor or major revisions.
|